Weathered and worn, we need new cushions to sit on

We desperately need new patio seat cushions for our table setting. They are over two years old with severe weather and sun damage.  Our delay in purchasing new seat cushions is the patterns that are available. We just don't like any of them.

I found a website www.thereplacementcushion.com. They have many different fabrics to choose from. I'm not completely crazy about any of them, but here are some of my favorites (stared).

Why are decisions like these so hard? It should be really simple right?

What are you updating outside?